VoteLab

FR

Council

We've modelled several systems, and several of them use different ballots.

One party, three ways to count it
FacebookThreads

We've modelled several systems, and several of them use different ballots. Tell us where you live in the city, and we will build a ballot for you for each option, naming real candidates who would likely appear on it. There is one ballot for ALBV and PAV, one for wards (FPTP), and a third for STV and STV+.

How we vote now:ALBV
A different way:
Vote for 10 seats city-wide
How to read this figure

Under At-Large Block Voting, the city elected the 10 councillors shown above.

Colours are the party of each councillor elected. How each ward is coloured is arbitrary, because council is elected city-wide.

Solid = seats your vote could affect · gold ring = a top-up seat
Vote for 10 seats city-wide
How to read this figure

Under Proportional Approval Voting, the city elected the 10 councillors shown above.

Colours are the party of each councillor elected. How each ward is coloured is arbitrary, because council is elected city-wide.

Solid = seats your vote could affect · gold ring = a top-up seat

Seats vs. votes across the council· Vancouver10 seats on council

At-Large Block Voting

ABC · 35% of the vote · 7 seatsGP · 11% of the vote · 2 seatsOneCity · 10% of the vote · 1 seatForward · 12% of the vote · 0 seatsTEAM · 8% of the vote · 0 seatsCOPE · 7% of the vote · 0 seatsNPA · 6% of the vote · 0 seatsProgress · 4% of the vote · 0 seatsInd · 3% of the vote · 0 seatsVision · 3% of the vote · 0 seatsVoteSocialist · 1% of the vote · 0 seatsAHC · 1% of the vote · 0 seats

Proportional Approval Voting

ABC · 35% of the vote · 5 seatsForward · 12% of the vote · 2 seatsGP · 11% of the vote · 1 seatOneCity · 10% of the vote · 1 seatCOPE · 7% of the vote · 1 seatTEAM · 8% of the vote · 0 seatsNPA · 6% of the vote · 0 seatsProgress · 4% of the vote · 0 seatsInd · 3% of the vote · 0 seatsVision · 3% of the vote · 0 seatsVoteSocialist · 1% of the vote · 0 seatsAHC · 1% of the vote · 0 seats
Icons = seats wonShaded = share of votes
  • ABC
  • Forward
  • Green
  • OneCity
  • COPE

City boundary: City of Vancouver, under the Open Government Licence – Vancouver. Ward shapes are schematic, not real boundaries.

Results where you would vote

Votes vs seats in the district shown above, under each way of voting.

At-Large Block Voting

Vancouver

Voting results summary: approvals city-wide

  • KIRBY-YUNG, SarahABCelected72,545 · 44.2%
  • DOMINATO, LisaABCelected70,415 · 42.9%
  • MONTAGUE, BrianABCelected68,618 · 41.8%
  • KLASSEN, MikeABCelected65,586 · 39.9%
  • MEISZNER, PeterABCelected63,275 · 38.5%
  • BLIGH, RebeccaABCelected62,765 · 38.2%
  • ZHOU, LennyABCelected62,393 · 38.0%
  • CARR, AdrianeGreenelected41,831 · 25.5%
  • BOYLE, ChristineOneCityelected38,465 · 23.4%
  • FRY, PeteGreenelected37,270 · 22.7%
  • ANDERSON, DulcyForwardrunner-up33,985 · 20.7%
  • BONAMIS, IonaOneCityrunner-up33,745 · 20.6%

Proportional Approval Voting

Vancouver

Weighted votes at the final count

  • KIRBY-YUNG, SarahABCelected14,995 · 9.1%
  • MONTAGUE, BrianABCelected14,145 · 8.6%
  • DOMINATO, LisaABCelected13,845 · 8.4%
  • BOYLE, ChristineOneCityelected13,329 · 8.1%
  • CARR, AdrianeGreenelected12,924 · 7.9%
  • KLASSEN, MikeABCelected12,438 · 7.6%
  • ZHOU, LennyABCelected12,316 · 7.5%
  • SWANSON, JeanCOPEelected12,261 · 7.5%
  • ANDERSON, DulcyForwardelected11,449 · 7.0%
  • TRUONG, TesiccaForwardelected11,367 · 6.9%
  • MEISZNER, PeterABCrunner-up11,727 · 7.1%
  • FRY, PeteGreenrunner-up11,087 · 6.8%
How the votes were counted

Under PAV your one vote is split evenly between the names you approved, so approving two gives each of them half a vote. When a candidate drops out, the ballots that named them share their weight out again among whoever is left. That repeats until only as many candidates remain as there are seats.

Cast a ballot in this district to watch your own vote move through the count.

Round 1 of 50

The first count: every ballot sits with its first choice.

  • KIRBY-YUNG, Sarah9,575 · 5.8%
  • DOMINATO, Lisa9,099 · 5.5%
  • MONTAGUE, Brian9,074 · 5.5%
  • KLASSEN, Mike8,501 · 5.2%
  • ZHOU, Lenny8,363 · 5.1%
  • CARR, Adriane4,874 · 3.0%
  • BOYLE, Christine4,360 · 2.7%
  • ANDERSON, Dulcy3,841 · 2.3%
  • TRUONG, Tesicca3,784 · 2.3%
  • SWANSON, Jean3,839 · 2.3%
  • ABC:bligh-rebecca7,996 · 4.9%
  • ABC:meiszner-peter8,086 · 4.9%
  • AHC:redmond-eric1,247 · 0.8%
  • COPE:ouellette-breen2,899 · 1.8%
  • COPE:trigueros-nancy2,207 · 1.3%
  • COPE:webking-tanya2,014 · 1.2%
  • Forward:ashe-jeanette2,510 · 1.5%
  • Forward:brown-hilary2,222 · 1.4%
  • Forward:singh-alvin3,303 · 2.0%
  • Forward:wvong-russil2,493 · 1.5%
  • GP:fry-pete4,343 · 2.6%
  • GP:singh-devyani2,423 · 1.5%
  • GP:smith-stephanie2,342 · 1.4%
  • GP:wiebe-michael3,532 · 2.2%
  • Ind:alm-k-r286 · 0.2%
  • Ind:bowen-mark693 · 0.4%
  • Ind:denofrio-dominic573 · 0.3%
  • Ind:fox-amy-evil-genius476 · 0.3%
  • Ind:franson-marlo336 · 0.2%
  • Ind:ly-tim414 · 0.3%
  • Ind:mackenzie-jeremy484 · 0.3%
  • Ind:peacock-amie345 · 0.2%
  • Ind:philbert-kyra372 · 0.2%
  • Ind:vargas-lina1,071 · 0.7%
  • NPA:allan-elaine1,288 · 0.8%
  • NPA:bhayani-cinnamon1,018 · 0.6%
  • NPA:charko-ken1,457 · 0.9%
  • NPA:de-genova-melissa3,379 · 2.1%
  • NPA:lee-morning1,881 · 1.1%
  • NPA:zarrabian-arezo1,263 · 0.8%
  • OneCity:bonamis-iona3,808 · 2.3%
  • OneCity:cromwell-ian3,302 · 2.0%
  • OneCity:norris-matthew3,303 · 2.0%
  • Progress:chin-david1,132 · 0.7%
  • Progress:francis-mauro767 · 0.5%
  • Progress:hayer-asha1,664 · 1.0%
  • Progress:he-may1,065 · 0.6%
  • Progress:oger-morgane1,126 · 0.7%
  • Progress:rosa-marie-noelle1,137 · 0.7%
  • TEAM:brown-cleta2,567 · 1.6%
  • TEAM:nardi-sean2,302 · 1.4%
  • TEAM:nijjar-param1,808 · 1.1%
  • TEAM:quan-grace2,214 · 1.3%
  • TEAM:roberts-stephen-p1,997 · 1.2%
  • TEAM:tieleman-bill2,133 · 1.3%
  • Vision:barzegari-honieh812 · 0.5%
  • Vision:boldt-lesli1,251 · 0.8%
  • Vision:mackinnon-stuart1,843 · 1.1%
  • VoteSocialist:orr-sean1,679 · 1.0%

How this works in general, for every system

Try voting for council

Cast a vote under each way of voting, with the ballot each one uses. Then see how it affects the results.